Whilst I do not like the style of patriotism expressed by those of the far right, does that mean that St. George becomes a figure to deride? Whilst it amuses me that those of the far right may not fully appreciate the irony of waving a flag associated with a Palestinian Roman soldier, a man who was martyred for standing up for his beliefs despite intense oppression has more in common with modern day heroes than we remember. My initial response has been to say that such right wing beliefs are wrong without trying to understand where they have grown from and why a nationalistic identity is so violently important to some in this land.
Our identity, both our own understanding of it and the way it is perceived by others, matters. We make judgements about people based on what we see or perceive we see; who we feel we are affects what we do. What research has taught me to do is to put those judgements to one side (as much as possible, I am human after all) and try and understand who people are and why they act how they do. By understanding their identity/ identities I can attempt to unravel the threads that have led to creating them as a person. We are complicated beings driven by many differing influences and needs and to understand someone as fully as possible we need to be open to all of their manifestations, even the ones we do not like.
This clash of St. George and identity met today in my first conversation with a pupil: "Miss, it's England day today and my house is covered with flags." If I try and put aside my personal bias I can use this simple conversation to try and understand him better, to get into his world and see that his self presentation is based on more than an isolated human being but is from family, socially and culturally generated ideals too. I still believe those who present such right wing beliefs are wrong but at least I have made some steps towards understanding why that identity matters so much to some. Maybe St. George wasn't such a bad guy after all.
Right now I'm interested in the connections between identity and belonging, especially at the macro end of things. Our kids are the socially excluded ones at school., in the local community...does national(istic) identity go some way to helping those kids and families feel they belong to something, however abstract? Ps got any references?
ReplyDeleteHi,
ReplyDeleteI do not have any specific nationalistic identity references but I am reading a lot about identity in general and the concept of transportable identities by Zimmerman. Let me fire up my laptop and I will get back to you!
So my identity reading has been:
ReplyDeleteStets and Burke (2000) A sociological approach to self and identity - patterns of behaviour and symbolic understanding
Polkinghorne (1991) Narrative and self concept
Van De Mieroop (2010) Making transportable identities relevant as persuasive device - discusses Zimmerman's three levels of identity
Cast (1999) Does the self conform to the views of others?
Bamberg (2011) Who am I? Narration and it's contribution to self and identity
A brief look on google scholar found these which I am going to download as you made me think:
Howard and Gill (2001) 'it's like we're a normal way and everyone else is different'
Waldron and Pike (2006) what does it mean to be Irish?
Hart (2004) beyond struggle and aid: children 'so identities in a Palestinian refugee camp
Bless you! What a star x
ReplyDelete